Lie: You are being investigated.
Truth: The "investigation"
is a simple little web page
sent to your browser by a program on
Robin Hood Software's computer after
you click on the Internet address for their "scare application" (which may be
disguised as a "fake link" as is encouraged by Robin Hood Software). It
prints out information on your computer to you. Other
than your IP address, Referral: header, and user agent information
(see my technical notes on that),
none of that information is available to anybody other than the
current user of your computer. This application is a scare tactic, nothing
more, intended to trick you into buying their software. (See also:
ICQ Updates, which
did a bit on this).
Lie: Their "investigations applet" can send them the contents of
my hard drive, and this is proven by the fact that they showed me a list
of the files on my system.
Truth: This is pure bunkum. There is a function
inside your web browser called an "inline frame" that,
when encountered in a web page,
will display the contents of a directory -- to you. It will NOT send that
data to a remote system! This "investigations applet" claims that people
can look at your system over the Internet. This is pure deceptive advertising,
and they are under investigation by the FTC for violating the
Truth in Advertising Act for this conduct.
If your browser supports inline frames and is on Windows, you may see a directory here. This is your own
hard drive -- just as if you were pointing Internet Explorer at "C:\". But NONE of that is being transmitted
over the Internet -- they *LIE* when they tell you different.
Lie: The Internet can put secret files on your computer
without your knowledge.
Truth: No, *YOU* can put "secret"
files on your computer, by browsing various web sites. I say "secret"
because they're hardly a secret -- we're talking about the list of
URL's that you visited, "web cookies" that various web sites have sent
you, and the image cache that your browser maintains in order to speed
future visits to the sites you browse. This is not some sort of deep
dark conspiracy on the part of Microsoft or The Government or
whatever, this is just how technology works. There are literally
dozens of programs available, both free and for pay, that will clean
out these cookie, history and cache files. See the Alternatives to Evidence Eliminator page
for more details.
Lie:
You can be put in jail or have big legal troubles for normal web browsing activities (see the
bogus warning that they
send to Windows users).
Truth: Only child pornography will get you tossed in jail, and
there's a pretty high burden of proof involved -- they have to prove
that you knowingly downloaded child pornography (i.e., that it wasn't
sent to you by mistake). It's a good thing to run a
disk cleaner/file wipe program
(which is what EE is) from
time to time anyhow to clean out temp files and such, but you don't have
to worry about Bubba -- the FBI isn't going to break down your door even
if you're browsing pornography, as long as it's not kiddie porn. (And if
it's kiddie porn, may you burn in hell forever!).
Lie:
Evidence Eliminator will save your job if you browse sex sites at work.
[Implied by their scare headlines about people fired for browsing sex sites
at work].
Truth: Installing Evidence Eliminator on your computer at work
(or any unauthorized software, for that matter) is grounds for firing at
most Fortune 500 companies and universities.
A $70 security scanner, which is similar to the products that most of the Fortune 500
use, will detect attempts to install Evidence Eliminator, allowing administrators
to take action.
Lie: Evidence Eliminator will cover up your tracks if you
browse sex sites at work.
Truth: At most of the Fortune 500, all outgoing web connections
go through what is known as a "proxy cache". This logs all attempts to
connect to external web sites. Generally this is also programmed to
detect attempts to connect to XXX web sites, and notify administrators that
the attempts are taking place.
Even if you managed to evade the security
scanners and managed to install Evidence Eliminator on your machine at
work, connections to XXX URL's are grounds for firing at most major
corporations. Note that employment here in the United States for most
"white collar" jobs is "at will", i.e., you can be fired at any time,
whether the "evidence" is still on your computer or not.
Lie: Evidence Eliminator can "defeat forensic equipment costing more than US$7000".
Truth: A $70 piece of
shareware defeats it! Reality is that if an employer or a TLA wants to know what's
on your computer, they'll install a bug in your computer to tell them
everything you do as you do it. Sounds farfetched? Not at all. Virtually
all corporate computers now are "locked down" and will report to the
security administrator when you attempt to install a program like
"Evidence Eliminator", and as for the computer bugs, the FBI did it
in the Scarfo case,
and probably has done it to thousands of others.
The FBI probably even has a VIRUS that'll do this so they don't even have to go into your home.
EE is worthless in
a corporate environment or if a TLA really wants you. But the EE guys won't
tell you that, they're too busy trying to bilk you out of your money.
Lie: Evidence Eliminator will cover your tracks if government
agencies are interested in you because you, say, download child pornography.
[Note that the only thing that you can get sent to jail for that you
get off the Internet is child pornography -- so their scare ads imply
that they'll save you from jail? They're saying they'll save you
if you download child pornography!]
Truth: The FBI has a system called "Carnivore" that is installed
at your ISP. If the FBI becomes interested in you, they can monitor everything
that goes through your Internet connection, and once they see incriminating
evidence go by, they will burst in and seize your
computer long before you have time for the lengthy and tedious process of
running Evidence Eliminator.
Lie: EE will save you if you download child porn (hey, they say it'll
keep you from being arrested by what you download off the Internet, and the
only thing that'll get you arrested is child porn):
Truth: Most sources
of child porn that you'll find on the Internet are actually FBI agents
working for the "Innocent Images" child pornography task force. If you
download child porn from them, your download is logged and you'll find
FBI agents knocking down your door and seizing your computer before you get
a chance to spend the hour or so deleting your files that Evidence Eliminator
takes (even if its shredding would defeat the FBI, which is questionable --
see above link).
Lie: Their web site says that "Actually we have never "Spammed". What is
Spamming, and what is clearly not "Spamming" is defined by a generally
respected Internet standard: "The Breidbart Index".
Truth: What they fail
to mention is that the Breidbart Index is merely an algorithm that is
used by the USENET cancelbots for automated cancelling (see the
Jargon Dictionary). Apparently their notion is that
"if we aren't caught by the cancelbots,
it's not a spam." Of course, that notion is
ridiculous. That's like saying "If I kill someone and am not caught, it's
not a murder." Hint: Whether you're caught or not, you're still guilty.
All it takes to see spam is to go to Google Groups and do a search
by date for the term "Evidence Eliminator". There were over 50 spams within
the last week alone the last time I did this search.
When confronted with this fact, Robin Hood Software alternately uses three different explanations: (1)the spams aren't "really" spams by Robin Hood Software because they're being done by affiliates, (2)the spams are a "joe job" by affiliates trying to get other affiliates kicked out of the affiliate program, or (AFDB time!), (3)the spams are all being posted by some vast New World Order conspiracy to destroy the cause of personal security and uhm, yeah, probably the Vatican and the Jews are part of this conspiracy to, uhm, yeah, uh huh, tell us another one Andy? Given that Robin Hood Software in its own EMAIL to affiliates encourages them to use ICQ, "push links", and other spammer tactics of that sort, and considering that Robin Hood Software has taken no effective action to eliminate the spam on the part of its affiliates (and, since they are acting as agents of the company, is responsible for their behavior in any event), it's hard to say that Robin Hood Software is innocent of spamming!
Lie:
This page is hate speech.
Truth: Hate speech has a number of definitions, but generally
hate speech is considered speech which advocates violence, or which
targets people based upon their race or sexual tendencies. You will
not find any such speech on this site. I advocate simply that you do
not buy software from scam artists. If that's hate speech, then
Consumer Reports is hate speech.
Lie:
They said (in May, 2001) that "Even the best Forensic Laboratory Analysis with
electron microscopes is no match for Evidence Eliminator's formidable
display of new, innovative, World-Leading data destruction
technologies."
Truth: When asked for the name of an independent testing lab
that has verifed this claim, you should have seen Andy duck and weave! And duck and weave and ...
Pshaw.
Given that they don't do Guttman shred (the only known software method
for doing this), this is yet another snow job. These guys ought to be
eligible for the Blizzard Award by now for "most snow on a single
website"! Talk about con artists...
Conclusion:Let's face facts, folks: These people are seriously truth-challenged. I don't know if they'd know truth if it lept up and bit them in the face. The truth of the matter is that what we have here is a perfectly acceptable little $39.95 disk cleaning product -- being sold for $150 via claims which are at best exaggerated, at worst pure hokum and bunk and probably illegal under the Truth in Advertising act in the United States (at least that's what the FTC says).
If you have been victimized by Robin Hood Software's deceptive advertising, file a complaint with the U.S. Federal Trade Comission. You may also wish to file a deceptive advertising complaint via the FTC's international complaints form, where they say they'll forward it to the proper UK authorities. Also notify Nottingham Trading Standards that someone in their jurisdiction is engaging in deceptive advertising. At that time you probably also want to file a complaint with Robin Hood Software's Internet Service Provider, UUNET-UK noting that Robin Hood Software is engaged in illegal activities in violation of UUNET's Acceptable Use Policy, though I doubt that it will do any good, since UUNET-UK appears to be a spammer haven ("We're MCI-Worldcom, we own half the Internet, you can't black-hole us for letting spammers use our network, so we don't have to care, nyah nyah nyah!").